“He Can Be [Aaron] Judge’s Caddy”: Trent Grisham Answers MLB Insider’s Criticism With Breakout Performance Against Brewers

The world of sports thrives on drama, on narratives that unfold in real-time, defying expectations and leaving fans on the edge of their seats. This is exactly the story that unfolded for New York Yankees outfielder Trent Grisham on Friday night. Just hours after being relegated to a complimentary role by veteran sports commentator Mike Francesa, Grisham silenced his doubters with a thunderous three-run home run against his former team, the Milwaukee Brewers.

This clutch hit, a turning point in the Bombers’ game against the Brew Crew, served as a powerful rebuttal to the commentary swirling around the young outfielder. Was it a lucky swing or a sign of things to come?

From “Caddy” to Clutch: Trent Grisham makes his mark

The timing of Grisham’s home run couldn’t have been a better example of poetic justice. Earlier that very day, veteran sports commentator Mike Francesa, known for his brash and often critical commentary, had relegated Grisham to a complimentary role on the Pinstripers: “I thought he was going to get days in center field, I still think he will, um, he can be (Aaron) Judge’s caddy. He’s a good center fielder. We know that he’s got left-handed power, he’s got speed—he’s 0 for the season.” Francesa’s statements suggesting his early season struggles meant Grisham might just be better suited as Judge’s “caddy,” is sort of a backhanded compliment, implying a lack of individual impact—which, undoubtedly, could have stung Grisham had he known about it.

It’s worth noting that Grisham wasn’t the only Bomber struggling to find his footing. The team, fresh off a disappointing loss, had been sputtering offensively. Judge, the team’s undisputed star, was hitting .178—but he hadn’t homered in two games. The rest of the lineup was riddled with inconsistency as well.

So when Grisham stepped up to the plate in the bottom of the fourth with two outs and the bases empty, the tension was thick. Here was a player facing public criticism, part of an underperforming team, and needing a spark to ignite both his own confidence and the Yankees’ offense. And ignite it he did!

Rather than succumbing to the pressure, Grisham displayed impressive composure. He battled for a crucial walk, extending the inning and keeping a glimmer of hope alive. Then, with two strikes on him and the count heavily in favor of the pitcher, the slugger unloaded on a pitch from Brewers reliever Colin Rea. The crack of the bat echoed through American Family Field as the ball soared majestically over the right-field wall, a three-run blast that instantly transformed the atmosphere.

Trent Grisham’s teammates erupted in cheers, the fans in the stands roared, and skipper Aaron Boone flashed a wide grin in the dugout. In a single swing, Grisham had silenced his doubters, injected life into a stagnant offense, and potentially rewritten his own narrative for the season. It was a dramatic shift in momentum, a real-life rebuttal to the commentary swirling around him.

“Excited for Him”: Yankees are thrilled with Grisham’s response

The joy in the Yankees dugout was palpable as Grisham rounded the bases, his teammates erupting in cheers. Manager Aaron Boone, a man who values resilience from his players, couldn’t have been happier. “Excited for him and that… Good at-bat to walk earlier and then really step on one to give us a lead at that time was big,” Boone said, beaming, acknowledging the importance of Grisham’s clutch hit to The New York Post.

It’s important to remember that context is king here in baseball. While Grisham’s struggles are undeniable—entering the game, he was 0-for-12—there’s a reason behind them.

Unlike the previous three seasons, where he consistently received more than 500 at-bats, Trent Grisham has found himself in an unfamiliar role as a part-timer, starting with the Yankees. This adjustment has undoubtedly impacted his rhythm and confidence. “It’s different, for sure,” Grisham admits. “There’s a lot of good people around me helping me out adjusting to a new role,” he added, acknowledging the support system within the team. Looking ahead, can the slugger maybe earn a more permanent role?

One game doesn’t erase a season’s worth of struggles, but Grisham’s performance against the Brewers serves as a potent reminder of his potential. The New York Yankees, ever in pursuit of a winning formula, will be closely monitoring his progress. Can he become a consistent contributor and solidify his place in the starting lineup? Or will he remain a part-time player searching for his groove? While the answer remains unwritten, one thing is clear: Trent Grisham has shown the baseball world—and perhaps more importantly, Mike Francesa—that he’s no one’s “Caddy.” He’s a ballplayer with a bat to swing and a point to prove, now.