On a crisp Florida morning, Dom Smith laced up his cleats, stepped onto the backfields of the Yankees’ complex, and took a few easy swings. It was just another day of spring training—until it wasn’t. Hours later, Smith stunned many by opting out of his minor-league deal with the Yankees, leaving the team just days before Opening Day.

At first glance, the move seemed confusing. Smith had put together a solid spring, slashing .297 with three homers and 12 RBIs. He looked like a strong depth option for the Yankees, especially with questions surrounding their bench. But baseball, like life, is about timing. Smith clearly believes that the right time for him is elsewhere.

Talkin’ Yankees confirmed the rumor on their official X (Twitter) account. “Dom Smith is opting out of his Yankees contract.” Smith’s decision signals confidence. He could have accepted a role in Triple-A, waiting for an opportunity to open up in the Bronx. Instead, he’s choosing to test the market now, betting that another club—perhaps one with more playing time available—sees value in his bat and veteran presence.

His departure also raises a bigger question: Did the Yankees miss something? The first base is locked up by Anthony Rizzo, and the DH role is crowded, but left-handed depth never hurts. If Dom Smith, a former Mets first-round pick, felt squeezed out, does that mean the Yankees are truly set, or did they miscalculate his potential role?

For the Yanks, this move might not seem like a big deal, but depth is often tested over a long season. Losing Smith means one fewer veteran option if injuries strike.

Dom Smith has made a career out of proving people wrong. His breakout with the Mets in 2020 showed his upside, and while he’s struggled for consistency since, he’s still just 29. By walking away now, he’s forcing teams to make a decision—do they believe in his bat as much as he does?

Spring training is about opportunity. Dom Smith saw him, and instead of waiting, he took control of his own fate. Now, the baseball world waits to see where he lands next.

Who’s calling? Teams that could use Dom Smith’s bat

The good news for Dom Smith? Teams are always looking for lefty bats with pop and a solid glove. The first base market isn’t deep, especially as teams make their final roster adjustments. Clubs like the Miami Marlins, still searching for offensive upgrades, could see Smith as a solid depth piece at first base or DH. The Cubs have been adjusting their lineup throughout the spring and might consider exploring options—especially if they aim to add another left-handed batter for roster balance. If Smith can effectively hit against right-paw pitchers, his presence could offer valuable support in the appropriate scenario.

In addition, there’s the Angels, a team constantly seeking hitters to enhance their lineup stability. A veteran like Smith could be the fit to complement their youthful core players. Even a reunion with the Mets isn’t out of the question, given their ongoing search for experienced depth options.

At just 29, Dom Smith isn’t washed—he’s waiting for the right fit. The question is, which team will take the chance first?