MLB’s official social media accounts are quite active, with baseball fans pouring their hearts out in the comments. But recently, there’s been a shift—NFL fans are joining the mix. Why? Because Los Angeles Dodgers star Shohei Ohtani just clinched a spot in the legendary 50-50 club – a record that is being celebrated across the entire sports world. Even the all-time greats from every post are chiming in, including Tom Brady. After Shohei’s incredible 51-51 performance at LoanDepot Park against the Miami Marlins, the NFL all-time hero was quick to share a heartfelt message congratulating him.

But here’s the twist: if you think the spotlight was on Tom Brady’s kind words, think again! The fans were lighting up the comments, not just for what Tom said or how he said it, but for the caption MLB crafted for the post. MLB shared Brady’s message where the New England Patriots legend said, “Congratulations. The first ever to be in the 50-50 club. What an accomplishment”. Getting such a thoughtful message from a 7-time Super Bowl champion is an achievement in all, and Tom not only congratulated him on his achievement but also gave him best wishes for the future,

Brady further noted, “But I know you have bigger goals ahead, so good luck in the postseason.” And yes, we agree the goal gets bigger for the baseball player every day. The slugger is already sitting at 53 home runs with a few games left, so there’s a real possibility we could see him reach the 55-55 club, right? Undoubtedly, Ohtani is having an incredible season, and MLB’s post captured that sentiment with the phrase, “A goat in awe of another.”

But even though many fans are on board with the comparison, some aren’t so convinced. They respect Ohtani’s gameplay but have raised points about why Tom Brady and Ohtani shouldn’t be compared at all. While the caption continued with, “Tom Brady is just like us when it comes to Shohei Ohtani”, when it comes to how MLB views the comparison between the two, it definitely wasn’t a “like us” moment for fans.

How did the fans react to the MLB’s post?

One of the fans who wasn’t so happy about the caption either chimed in with a fair point. Even though Ohtani is a phenomenal player, the 2024 season marks his first shot at the postseason. Meanwhile, the man he has been quoted alongside as a “GOAT” won 7 Super Bowl championships, and Ohtani hasn’t won a championship yet in MLB. So, comparing Ohtani to Brady seemed a bit off when it comes to postseason success; it might be a long shot for a few fans.

A similar sentiment was echoed by another commenter  After all, Ohtani  debuted in MLB six years ago in 2018, and he still has at least another decade to prove himself. Meanwhile, Tom Brady has played 23 seasons in the NFL, cementing his legacy with his titles. So, it’s understandable that fans feel that the comparison is premature.

A different yet similar vibe, came by another Ohtani’s admirer focusing on the fact while Ohtani isn’t a GOAT just yet, there’s a strong belief that he’s on his way to becoming one. Plus, it’s pretty special to see someone like Tom Brady, who’s been to 10 Super Bowl championships and holds the record for the most wins in NFL history, congratulating a baseball star who’s still carving out his legacy.

While talking about legends congratulating the baseball slugger, one fan nailed it with the sentiment that how great is to see how everyone depsite of different releams are there for one another. And in the list Tom Brady isn’t the only one. Other sports stars have come forward to congratulate Ohtani too. Basketball legend LeBron James and NFL superstar, Patrick Mahomes, have also joined in the praise.

Another user really let their feelings out with a heated take, but one can sense where he is coming from! Undoubtedly, baseball has seen a ton of incredible talent this season. Aaron Judge is on fire, and Juan Soto is in top form. So, Ohtani isn’t the only one playing well. Plus, his injury has limited his pitching, which complicates things. While his hitting is nothing short of magnificent, fans are left wondering: Is it enough to claim the GOAT title?

That’s definitely subjective! According to David Ortiz, it’s quite unfair that Ohtani is still in the MVP race despite only being a DH. Especially since Ortiz himself was never awarded the MVP for playing the same position. But regardless of the mixed feelings from fans, Ohtani is fully committed to the MVP race and making his first postseason appearance. So, what do you think? Will he be able to clinch the series and further cement his legacy? Drop your thoughts in the comments.