When you hear the name Derek Jeter, you might think of baseball legends, World Series titles, and unforgettable moments on the field. Recently, he’s been in the spotlight for a different reason: rumors swirling that his rejection to not play in the New York Yankees‘ Old Timer’s Day game kept the event from happening. Old Timer’s Day is a special event for Yankees fans, where former players gather to relive glory days, much like a family reunion with Yankees legends.

But for some years, fans have felt disappointment when they learned that Derek Jeter might not play. Naturally, speculation arose that the Yankees’ decision to skip the game was heavily influenced by Jeter’s absence. Upon asking, Jeter quickly gave his reasons, also adding that the question should be redirected to the proper authorities and not him, scared that he might get blamed for it later. So, could one player’s decision truly impact an entire event that means so much to fans?

Derek Jeter has been setting the record straight  

Derek Jeter has continued to insist that he would never play in an Old-Timers’ Day game. He does not want to get injured, moreover, the 50-year-old dismissed the claims that connected him to the Yankees ending their historic practice. “But that’s not saying the reason, there’s no game is because I’m not playing,” Jeter said when asked if his absence has anything to do with the game not being held altogether. “I don’t make those decisions when it comes to whether there’s a game or not. So why are you asking me? You can direct [that question] to Hal [Steinbrenner],” he further added.   

Saturday marked the 76th Old-Timers’ Day at Yankee Stadium. The roster of invitees included Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, CC Sabathia, Hideki Matsui, Jorge Posada, and first-time Yankee Old-Timer Alex Rodriguez. Amongst the noticeably missing was Brett Gardner, who hasn’t visited the Stadium since the team decided not to re-sign him after the 2021 campaign. While the game has been suspended since Covid (2020), there is still hope that someday it will be resumed and give the fans what they want. 

Old Timer’s Day Game gets mixed reactions from other Yankees legends  

Exhausting himself over a stellar 19-year MLB career, CC Sabathia has a rebuilt left shoulder. Still, the 44-year-old former workhorse for the Yankees would have been delighted to toss a couple of pitches, had the Old Timers’ Day at Yankee Stadium not been suspended. “I’m still (ticked) we’re not playing,’’ said Sabathia, although his shoulder is ‘just good for catch and golf’. Although some of his former colleagues didn’t share his enthusiasm about playing a baseball game on Old-Timers’ Day, Sabathia proposed that perhaps even a softball game would suit the occasion. 

Former major league teammate of Jeter and 2009 World Series MVP Hideki Matsui, was practically undecided, while former catcher Jorge Posada felt glad that there was no game. While there is no solid news of the game reviving, the fans expect that the Yankees will undoubtedly continue to host this nostalgic event. One thing to remember is that while players may come and go, the traditions remain. Old Timer’s Day is about the bonds formed through baseball—those shared moments that turn into lifelong memories.

Do you think the Yankees should revive their Old-Timers’ Day game? Share below.