The New York Yankees are no strangers to high expectations. The team is always under pressure to make moves that will propel them toward their ultimate goal: another World Series title. Whether it’s acquiring star players or making key trades, the Yankees are constantly looking for ways to improve. However, not all of their decisions seem to be as smooth as they’d hoped—one such instance being Marcus Stroman’s deal.

The problem with the New York Yankees trading right-hander Marcus Stroman lies in a key stipulation in his contract: the $18 million player option for the 2026 season, which activates if he pitches 140 innings in 2025. So the teams eyeing Stroman should not only be concerned about factors like age and recent performance but also this clause significantly complicating any potential trade

Thus, teams acquiring Stroman would have to account for the possibility that he could be on their roster for two years rather than just one. Moreover, this trade would involve taking on an additional financial commitment for a player who hasn’t consistently been dominant in recent seasons. While Stroman pitches well enough to reach the 140 mark in 2025, the acquiring team could be stuck with a $18 million salary for a second year, even if his performance declines.

For the Yankees, it is a tough situation as they are cost-cutting salaries and making space for their future acquisitions. However, moving Marcus Stroman with such an option marks a limited pool of interested teams, as the financial risks tied to it outweigh the perceived value he can bring to a new roster. Also, if no deal takes place, the Yankees may have to rethink their strategy to facilitate one.

Alternatively, they might have to wait for a team desperate enough for pitching depth and overlook beyond the financial constraints tied with it. So, instead of offloading Stroman to clear space, what if the Yankees invest in finding ways to unlock the potential that made him a consistent innings-eater in the past?

Yankees’ case for keeping Marcus Stroman

The answer lies in his abilities; while Stroman’s stats last year weren’t as impressive, with an ERA of 4.07 in 2024, he has consistently been a durable pitcher. So, with pitching depth often being tested by injury concerns, the Yankees could get a reliable backup in a veteran like Marcus Stroman, given the uncertainty surrounding other pitchers in the rotation.

Moreover, the Yankees could benefit from a strategic approach where they keep Stroman for the short term and allow him to rebuild his value. Then, they can trade him at midseason if the market allows—it’s a decision where they need to weigh the potential financial impact on the entire roster against the perks of having an experienced pitcher who can provide depth. So, whether they choose to keep him or manage his contract in another way, the decision will have repercussions on the team’s payroll, squad depth, and overall competitiveness in the upcoming 2025 season.

As this transfer saga unfolds, the question remains: Will the Yankees take the risk of keeping Stroman hoping he will deliver, or will they look out for another way for his exit? What do you predict? Share with us below.