David Stearns’s initial period with the New York Mets has met with some criticism, not for his lack of ambition or activity but because of the puzzling choice to enlist Frankie Montas, which has puzzled Mets supporters. Montas, whose deal came with a hefty $19 million price tag, has failed to live up to expectations, leaving Stearns looking like he might have missed the mark on this one.

When Stearns brought Montas in, there were hopes that the right-hander would add some stability to the rotation. But instead of contributing, Montas’ performance has been a disaster. His underwhelming outings raised doubts about whether he’s a reliable option, especially with the Mets now stuck with his hefty contract. And for a team that should be more focused on solidifying its pitching depth, Montas feels like an expensive gamble that didn’t pay off.

David Stearns’s risky bet on Montas backfires

Sal Licata, WFAN Sports host, didn’t mince words when discussing the deal on X, “You could’ve spent that money elsewhere, like Walker Buehler. Money before you get started, you’re losing one of your prized possessions in the off-season as far as that rotation goes.” He added, “David Stearns was begging to get ripped with that Frankie Montas.”

Licata’s criticism underscores the missed opportunities elsewhere, like securing a more reliable asset like Buehler instead of a pitcher who’s yet to prove his worth in a Mets uniform. In terms of immediate impact, Montas’ failure opens the door for other Mets pitchers to step up, with Tyler McGill likely to fill the gap. McGil and individuals such as David Peterson have the ability to maintain a competitive rotation. However, Stearns should take this as a cautionary sign. Roster choices of this nature (big money) can be pivotal in determining whether a team remains a playoff contender or gets stuck in uncertainty.

The next logical step for Stearns and the Mets might be to look outside the organization for help. Dylan Cease, anyone? With a rotation still in need of a solid anchor, it seems that David Stearns’ next move is crucial to avoid further fallout from the Montas misfire.

The road ahead: will Stearns make a move for Dylan Cease?

The Mets are in need of a pitcher since Frankie Montas hasn’t been performing up to par; Dylan Cease is being considered as a choice to fill that role. Cease, currently playing with the Padres, had a solid season in 2024 where he gained recognition for his ability to strike out batters and deliver consistent performances on the field. Having achieved a 3.35 ERA and an impressive tally of 224 strikeouts in 187 innings played makes him an appealing choice for the Mets rotation as their need for consistency. However, acquiring him may come at a cost, with a trade package likely needed to secure his services.

Other promising players that could be involved in the trade deal include prospects like shortstop Ronny Mauricio and outfielder Alex Ramirez, who have been making waves in the Mets organization recently. If David Stearns is really looking to bring Cease on board for the team’s pitching rotation, he’ll have to consider making some moves within the farm system. Potentially parting ways with multiple prospects and maybe even a player who’s already fit for major league action to seal the trade with San Diego.

David Stearns faces a pivotal choice—stick with the Mets’ current rotation or pay a steep price for Dylan Cease. What do you think? Will Stearns take the gamble to solidify the Mets’ postseason hopes?