“Clearly Legendary!”: Heated Debate Over Derek Jeter’s Bloody Play Resurfaces Among MLB Fans 18 Years Later

Derek Jeter is one of the most clutch baseball players of all time. He performed well during the regular season, but once the postseason started, he used to play on another level altogether. Hence, he is widely considered one of the greatest postseason performers of all time. Jeter did this through consistently good play, clutch hits, and dazzling defensive technique. Furthermore, he was always ready to put his body on the line to win games.

But Jeter has always been a player to cause debate, with many followers of the game commenting on his career. Most recently, a heated debate broke out on Twitter over one of his most iconic plays.

Was “The Dive” by Derek Jeter a legendary play or not?

On July 1s, 2004, the New York Yankees were in an extra innings game against the Boston Red Sox. The game was tied 3-3 in the 12th inning when the Red Sox got a hit that would have broken the deadlock. But Jeter ran after the ball and caught it. The legendary shortstop couldn’t stop his momentum and ended up in the stands. Twitter user Baseball in Pics shared an image on Twitter and asked fans whether the play was legendary or not. 

In the tweet, Baseball in Pics said, “Derek Jeter dives into the stands, July 1, 2004. Is this is a legendary play or overrated?”. This Tweet has started an intense debate among baseball fans.

Read More: “That’s Just an Excuse”– Hall of Famer Derek Jeter Once Revealed the Upbringing Instilled in Him for Working Harder Than Anyone Else

Some fans said that the play is indeed legendary and lauded the effort that Jeter put into it.

Other fans criticized the play and called it overrated.

Regardless of all the opinions, it will always be considered one of Jeter’s most clutch plays. With a tied game against his rival Red Sox, Jeter kept the game alive with his play. Furthermore, he put his body in harm’s way to do so. Luckily, the result went the Yankees’ way.

Jeter’s dive play helped the Yankees win the game

Following Derek Jeter’s 12th-inning heroics, the New York Yankees managed to put another run on the board. This helped them win the game and secured this play among Jeter’s top defensive moments. In fact, the legendary Yankees shortstop even revisited the dive play.

Watch this story: From Alex ‘A-Rod’ Rodriguez to Derek Jeter: Here are the top 5 richest MLB players of all time

What do you think about “The Dive” play by Derek Jeter? Is it legendary or overrated? Kindly share your thoughts in the comments below!