The New York Yankees are currently facing challenges in re-signing outfielder Juan Soto. Reports suggest that they are now considering a different approach by looking into investing $189 million in former Milwaukee Brewers shortstop Willy Adames. This shift in strategy reflects both their ambition and mounting frustration in the Soto sweepstakes.

The Yankees have been eagerly eyeing Soto as a player for their season plans and envision a powerful combo with Aaron Judge in their lineup. However, the challenges in finalizing a deal prompted them to consider options, and this is where Adames comes in—a dynamic two-way player who could potentially strengthen the team’s infield and provide much-needed offensive stability.

The New York Yankees balancing big moves with smart spending

Willy Adames is 29 years old and recently came off a stellar performance with the Brewers team. During that time, he proved himself as a standout shortstop in the MLB. The 2024 season was particularly impressive for Adames, as he achieved a batting average of .261 along with hitting 28 home runs, driving in 89 RBIs, and an OPS of .803. His defensive skills were equally noteworthy as he managed to save 15 runs (DRS), placing him among the top five shortstops in the league.

The Yankees‘ interest in Adames roots from a desire to enhance their lineup for the upcoming season. Although Anthony Volpe showed promise in his rookie season, his .209 batting average and struggle at shortstop made it clear that seasoned players were needed. Moreover, Gleyber Torres, a second base player, is reaching the year of arbitration, and DJ LeMahieu’s declining stats of (.243/.317/.371), have further strained their roster depth. So, bringing Willy Adames on board would ensure a presence at the position and could lead to Volpe switching to second base, forming a dynamic middle infield partnership.

The Yankees are showing their belief in Adames’ worth by offering him a $189 million figure. The deal positions him as one of the top-paid shortstops in the league, alongside players like Francisco Lindor ($341 million), Corey Seager ($325 million), and Trea Turner ($300 million). Adamess’s consistent performance with over 150 games played in three seasons adds to his attractiveness as a player.

While fans eagerly await news of a superstar addition like Soto, the Yankees’ pursuit of Adames reflects a more nuanced strategy. The team must address shortcomings that contributed to a lackluster 2024 campaign, where they finished fourth in the AL East with an 82-80 record, their worst in nearly three decades.

Willy Adames as a new Core? How young players could benefit.

Adding Willy Adames to the roster could redesign the Yankees’ infield and directly impact the development of their young stars. Anthony Volpe, who debuted in 2024 with 21 home runs and 24 stolen bases but struggled with a .209 batting average, might move to second base, where his defensive strengths could shine with less pressure. Such a shift would allow Volpe to focus on refining his approach at the plate while still contributing as a dynamic baserunner.

Similarly, Oswald Peraza, known for his defensive versatility, could slot into a utility role, giving the Yankees more flexibility while ensuring he still gets regular playing time. Jasson Domínguez, the highly touted outfield prospect, could also benefit indirectly from Willy Adames signing. By stabilizing the infield and improving team defense, the Yankees could create a more supportive environment for young players to focus on their specific roles.

Domínguez impressed during his brief MLB stint before suffering a UCL injury, hitting four home runs in eight games. As he returns, having a more balanced roster could ease the pressure on him to immediately perform at a superstar level. In the end, the move underscores the front office’s readiness to pivot and act decisively, ensuring they remain competitive in the AL East.