Alex Bregman is anticipated to secure a lucrative contract in the ballpark of $300 million—a figure that could potentially reflect Manny Machado’s deal. As Bregman approaches his prime years in baseball with his agent, Scott Boras, Alex’s market value is expected to mirror his position as one of the sought-after talents in the market. However, the Houston Astros are now confronted with a dilemma regarding Bregman’s future.

Bregman’s value in the market is going up, which means he might become a choice for agents soon. Bregman’s steady performance on offense and his role as a leader in the Astros team make him an important figure. While the team has a history of being cautious when it comes to long-term deals, now, they are under pressure to retain some of their key players. The proposed contract is expected to be for around eight to ten years. If this agreement is finalized, it would surpass the high-value contracts in Houston, highlighting the team’s determination to stay competitive in the AL West division.

The Astros to make a tough call; will they move on or go all out?

Luke Arcaini recently posted on X, “Ken Rosenthal “suspects” Alex Bregman and Scott Boras are “aiming higher” than most projections.” He wrote, “Specifically, at a deal closer to 11-year, $350 million deal that Manny Machado signed in February 2023.” Houston is currently dealing with high arbitration expenses for players such as Kyle Tucker and Framber Valdez, who are expected to get contracts. Owner Jim Crane has noted that the Astros are actively working to secure Bregman but are also preparing for the scenario where he might leave the team in the future.

In contrast to José Altuve, whose contract extension was simpler due to his age factor, Alex Bregman being younger and demanding a salary could prompt the Astros to explore strategies for the future. Managing these commitments, alongside Bregman’s salary demands, will need careful planning within the team. However, a change in the Astros’ strategy is not unexpected, given their track record of allowing star players to leave the team without contract extensions in the past. Houston’s choice not to renew contracts for names like Carlos Correa and George Springer was influenced by considerations and a focus on building a sustainable roster over time.

The team will now require filling the positions on the roster, like base and relief pitching, which adds another layer of complexity to the situation. If Bregman’s price tag reaches around the $300 million mark or more, the Astros might decide to go for a budget option—they are aware of the financial circumstances that could change in the years ahead.

Future options for the Astros other than Alex Bregman

If the Astros decide to move on from Alex Bregman, they have several choices to consider. The team could look within their roster and consider Mauricio Dubón, who’s skilled in various positions on the field, or possibly turn to prospect Zach Dezenzo, who has displayed potential with his batting skills in the minor leagues. While both options provide versatility, they may not quite reach Bregman’s level of proficiency. Houston’s farm system has proven to be a source in the past few years; however, the absence of a top-tier third base prospect ready for Major League Baseball might compel them to seek talent externally.

Free agent options might involve players such as Matt Chapman or Jeimer Candelario, who could bring a balance of defensive skills and hitting power to solidify the team’s infield position. On another front, the Houston team could also look into trade options for players like Ke’Bryan Hayes or Ryan McMahon—talents with long-term potential. Leveraging their strong existing team lineup can help the Astros secure a lasting solution at the position; these strategic moves wouldn’t just address the gap in the team but also demonstrate their commitment to maintaining a sustainable winning team while still managing their finances effectively.

However, losing Alex Bregman could potentially push their team to the edge in the AL West division. It will also have a significant impact on the franchise’s future direction and success over the next few years, regardless of the route they take. So, what’s your prediction on Bregman’s future in the team? Share in the comments below.