5 Times World Series Champion Paul O’Neill Recalls His Best New York Yankee Moment That Solidified His Legacy

A 1996 World Series game will forever be etched in the minds of New York Yankees fans, as it was the night Paul O’Neill made a catch for the ages. The legendary outfielder has won the World Series 5 times. The only player ever to wear the number 21 for the team, soared through the air to snare a fly ball, helping secure a crucial victory for the Yankees. 

The streets of New York erupted in celebration the next day. As the city collectively reveled in the glory of their beloved team. Even today, O’Neill still recalls the moment with crystal-clear clarity.

There was nothing like winning with the Yankees for Paul O’Neill

When Paul O’Neill took the field at Yankee Stadium during the 1996 World Series, he knew that he was about to experience something truly special. The roar of the crowd, the history and traditions of the team, and the pressure to bring home a victory all converged to create a moment that would be seared into his memory forever. When the final out was recorded, and the Yankees had secured their victory, the feeling had been euphoric, not only for the players but for the fans as well. 

O’Neill was not only a part of a winning team, but he played a crucial role in it. The streets of New York erupted in celebration the next day, and the parade that followed was a once-in-a-lifetime experience. At that moment, O’Neill understood the true magnitude of playing for the Yankees.

READ MORE: If He Had His Way, Derek Jeter Would Have Had the New York Yankees Retire a Different Jersey Number

This is how O’Neill narrates it, “They live and die by who won the night before. And I love that about New York.”

The New York Yankees retired O’ Neill’s number last year 

Paul O’Neill will forever be remembered as a key player in the New York Yankees’ dynasty. Last year, the team paid a tribute to his legacy by retiring his number 21. According to mlb.com, He joined an elite group of 23 Yankees players who have had their numbers retired by the team. The most recent being Derek Jeter’s number 2. 

The honor of having your number retired is proof of the impact a player has made on the team and on the game of baseball. And for O’Neill, this is only the beginning, as he becomes eligible for the Hall of Fame via the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee at the end of this year.

WATCH THIS STORY: From Babe Ruth To Derek Jeter: New York Yankees Icons Whose Jersey Number Has Been Retired