Is Scottie Scheffler’s reticent personality a hindrance? The current world No. 1 golfer and two-time Masters champion, Scottie Scheffler, has enthralled the golf community with his extraordinary abilities and calm on-course manner.

His development from a young prodigy to a mainstay in golf is a result of his commitment and the wise counsel of Randy Smith, his longtime coach. However, some sources think Scheffler’s quiet demeanor may be causing him to be perceived as “underrated” by both the media and fans. 

Insider suggests Scottie Scheffler should alter his public persona

Jaime Diaz, a golf historian, recently discussed Scheffler’s public portrayal on an episode of the Fried Egg Golf Podcast. Diaz stated, “Scottie Scheffler, I think he’s underrated in some ways, maybe because to some people he’s not… I won’t say flamboyant, but he’s not enough of an extrovert.” He described Scheffler as a “very controlled thinker and a very controlled speaker and a very controlled golfer,” emphasizing that this discipline is a significant strength. 

Diaz admitted that although Scheffler has a vibrant inner life and a sense of humor with friends, his public persona is characterized by a reserved and focused manner. This calm demeanor carries over into his gameplay, as he exhibits exceptional poise even in the face of obstacles. According to Diaz, “He kind of shut down all the talk about it, which is difficult to do in a nice way.”

The implication that Scheffler’s introverted demeanor is a factor in his “underrated” status begs the question of how a golfer’s personality and public opinion interact. Scheffler stands out in a time when figures with charisma frequently make headlines because of his quiet confidence and methodical approach. Although some could see his quiet approach as a barrier to his recognition, others contend that it highlights his professionalism and dedication, which has surely helped him succeed on the course. While there is a dispute about whether Scheffler needs to speak up more, his performance, which was greatly aided by Randy Smith, speaks for itself.

Scheffler carries on the tradition of MASTERS ’25

With the 2025 Masters Tournament drawing near, Scheffler is the center of attention as he looks to become the third person to win the green jacket in four years—a feat that only the great Jack Nicklaus has accomplished. Longtime coach Randy Smith, Scheffler’s mentor since he was six, has played a pivotal role in his development.

Smith, the renowned head professional at Dallas’ Royal Oaks Country Club since 1980, has a long history of producing elite golfers. Scheffler’s rise in the golf industry was aided by his coaching philosophy, one that emphasizes simplicity and an extensive knowledge of the golf swing. Under Smith’s guidance, Scheffler has developed a broad skill set that enables him to negotiate the intricacies of Augusta National and other courses confidently and precisely.

Sign up to Essentially Golf

Join 180K+ golf enthusiasts who trust our 'Whole in One' newsletter for the latest trends, exclusive insights, and all the big news in the world of golf.

Scheffler and Smith’s connection is an outstanding instance of the significant influence a committed coach can have on a player’s career. Smith’s impact goes beyond technical education; he cultivates a culture of excellence by instilling principles of dedication and strenuous effort. This long-lasting relationship is evidence of the value of mentoring in attaining long-term success in professional golf, as Scheffler gets ready for the Masters.