Home/Golf

USA Today via Reuters

USA Today via Reuters

0
  Debate

Debate

Does the Ryder Cup's history make it superior to the Presidents Cup in terms of prestige and excitement?

The Ryder Cup and the Presidents Cup are team events. Does that mean they are utterly similar? No, a few paramount differences separate the two. If there is one keen similarity between the two, it is that Team USA lies at the heart of both tournaments. While the Ryder Cup has Team U.S.A. lock horns with Team Europe, the Presidents Cup has Team U.S.A. face the best players from across the world, except Europe.

Both tournaments have two teams of 12 players, where 6 are auto-qualified and the other six are handpicked by the skipper. Notably, team U.S.A. has dominated the Presidents Cup, but there is still a fair amount of competition in the Ryder Cup. Let’s have a look at the key differences and similarities between the two contests.

Format and duration

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Both of these team-based events are played once every two years. The American vs. European teams compete over 3 days, whereas Team International and Team USA take on each other for 4 days. A total of 28 matches are played in the Ryder Cup. The four foursomes and fourball matches are played in the first two days. Additionally, 12 single matches are played on the last day. The Presidents Cup follows the same format as the Ryder Cup in the later stages. A total of 30 matches are played, in which the first two days feature five matches of fourball or foursomes.

Points System

The winning team needs 14.5 points to lift the Ryder Cup. For the Presidents Cup, the winning team needs 15.5 points. In the event of a tie, the trophy is shared in the Presidents Cup, but in the Ryder Cup, the defending champions retain the title. You can have your inhibitions about the tie rule of the latter, but this is how it works.

via Reuters

Location

What’s your perspective on:

Does the Ryder Cup's history make it superior to the Presidents Cup in terms of prestige and excitement?

Have an interesting take?

In the Ryder Cup, locations are alternated between America and Europe every two years. For instance, the 2023 Ruder Cup was held at Marco Simone in Europe, and the upcoming edition, that is the 2025 one, will be held at Bethpage in America. Whereas, the Presidents Cup changes venues every time.

The venue of the Presidents Cup changes every time with no fixed pattern since the American squad competes against players from all the countries except European ones. Hence, the venue can be anywhere except Europe. This year’s edition will be held at the Royal Montreal Golf Club in Canada from September 26 to September 29.

Player Qualification

This is where the major difference comes in when we talk about these competitions. Talking about the Presidents Cup, six qualifiers for Team International are based on their world rankings. For Team US, players qualify automatically as per the FedEx Cup points they have collected over the qualifying period.

For the 2025 Ryder Cup, Team Europe will have a single Ryder Cup Points List, which will use a tournament banding structure, with some events offering more points than others. Team USA has its own Ryder Cup Points List. The list offers points based on each $1,000 earned.

A similarity between these competitions’ selection processes is the number of automatic qualifiers (6), with captains completing their teams with the help of six picks of their choice.

Schedule

Both the Presidents Cup and the Ryder Cup are held every two years. But the Presidents Cup is mostly held in even-numbered years and the Ryder Cup in odd-numbered years.

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

However, external factors have changed this format twice. The 9/11 attacks forced the Ryder Cup to be postponed to 2002, after which it was held in even-numbered years. This was changed again due to the COVID-19 pandemic, due to which the tournament was delayed to 2021 instead of 2020.

To accommodate this, the Presidents Cup shifted its schedule to odd-numbered years to prevent any clashes with the Ryder Cup.

Team Setup

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

The Ryder Cup became a competition between Team USA and Team Europe in 1979. From 1927 to 1971, it was a competition between Team USA and Great Britain. Britain also included Ireland in 1973. The matchup of Team U.S.A. and Team International started in 1994. The purpose of this new yet somewhat similar competition was to bring in players who were left out of the Ryder Cup because they did not belong to Europe.

While these two are some of the most prominent tournaments in golf, the Ryder Cup shows more passion and interest than its counterpart. Do you think that will ever change, considering how Europe has a better connection with the sport? Let us know in the comments below!