Justin Thomas’s 2024 season wasn’t exactly what you would call the most amazing one. It was another year without a win, extending a worrying streak that’s been going since May 2022. Yes, it’s been a while since JT last lifted a trophy, and fans are done playing the waiting game. So, has he lost his magic? Not at all. If anything, 2024 was a year of “almosts.” He was so close, yet the final peak stayed just out of reach. But here’s the thing—he never stopped fighting.

And now, as the season has started, with The Sentry being the first tournament of the year from January 2, JT is back with full force. This time, he’s coming in strong and determined to flip the script. He even talked about aiming for a season like Scottie Scheffler’s last year. Now, that has kept the fans talking!

Sure, he admitted the odds weren’t exactly in his favor, but as he said, “I think I would be doing myself a disservice if I didn’t think I could at least do that.”

This confidence levels feels like a milestone for a guy who’s usually pretty hard on himself. And honestly, after more than two and a half years—without a win, maybe a little self-belief is exactly what he needs.

That said, it’s not just about JT anymore—it’s about how fans view his game. Sure, he’s still got that swing magic; we saw that in Japan during the Zozo Championship where he finished second. There were many such moments where it felt like the win was just one shot away. Yet, time and time again, it slipped through his fingers.

So, when NUCLR GOLF asked, “Can he do it?” fans had mixed reactions. There’s hope, sure, but also doubts—because 956 days is a long time to wait.

Fans’ views don’t align with Justin Thomas’s hopes

While Justin Thomas is stepping into 2025 with sky-high optimism, the fan reactions tell a completely different story. After nearly three years without a win, it seems JT’s bold claim about having a “Scottie Scheffler-type year” hasn’t exactly convinced everyone. Take this fan’s take, for example: “Yeah right. Think about maybe actually doing it before you predict it JT. Otherwise you are just full of sh*t.” Ouch. But honestly, who can blame them? Confidence is great, but it hasn’t translated into results for Thomas lately.

Another fan wasn’t shy about pointing out where JT really needs to step it up, saying, “Maybe start with being in contention on a Sunday. It’s been years!!” And they’re not wrong. Being in the mix during the final rounds has been rare for Thomas. In 2024, he teed it up in 20 events and made the cut in 16. The rest? Missed cuts.

And let’s talk about that optimism for a second—fans aren’t exactly sold. “Good to be optimistic! But nah, ain’t happening JT, sorry,” wrote one fan. And as he mentioned World No. 1’s name, the comparison was expected, even if JT didn’t exactly sign up for them.

Last year, Scheffler secured seven official PGA Tour victories, including his second Masters title in April and a second consecutive Players Championship win. He also earned the PGA Tour Player of the Year award, matching a record set by Tiger Woods. Naturally, someone chimed in, “Nope, don’t see him ever coming close to a Scottie season.”

And then there’s the added pressure. Another fan pointed out, “Why say it out loud – now he has double the pressure.” It’s a fair point. Putting that kind of target on your back might just make things harder. While others believe he is a daydreamer. “I think they call that delusional,” a fan wrote.

JT’s confidence is great, but let’s be honest—the gap between where his game is right now and the big goals he’s setting is tough to overlook. Can he close that gap and shut the doubters up? That’s what everyone’s going to be keeping an eye on as the season plays out. What do you think? Will Thomas make it happen in 2025? Let us know in the comments!