Brandel Chamblee Undermines Jack Nicklaus’s Greatness by Pulling Out Figures, Leaving Fans Outraged

The debate over who’s the greatest golfer of all time—Jack Nicklaus or Tiger Woods—has sparked countless discussions. With Nicklaus holding a record 18 major titles and Woods dazzling fans with his incredible comebacks, it’s no surprise this rivalry has been heated for years. Now, Nicklaus is weighing in on why Woods might struggle to surpass his legendary career.

His impressive streak of competing in every major from 1962 to 1998, according to Nicklaus, highlights not only his physical but also his mental strength. However, former American professional golfer and commentator, Brandel Chamblee begs to differ. He took to his official X account and replied to a tweet that stated that Jack Nicklaus is the greatest player of all time.  “In major wins, yes he is.” Ben Hogan turned professional at just 17, nearly six months before his 18th birthday.

Despite finishing 13th on the money list in 1938, Hogan was still required to take an assistant proposition, which led to him being hired by Century Country Club that same year. He remained at Century, refining his skills, until 1941. Throughout his career from 1938 to 1959, Hogan claimed an impressive 63 professional victories, overcoming setbacks like World War II and a near-fatal car accident during his prime.  His nine major championships place him tied for fourth all-time.

Taking to this, Chamblee even added, “But what if Hogan’s career hadn’t been interrupted by WW II AND his accident in 1949? What if Hagen had 4 majors to play in instead of three in his prime, and for that matter, if the powers that be hadn’t demoted the Western Open from its “major championship” status?”

That was not all for the comparisons. He even brought in Bobby Jones. In 1930, Bobby Jones made history by winning both the British Amateur and British Open, earning a second ticker-tape parade in New York. Afterward, he returned to Atlanta for another parade with 125,000 Georgians. But Jones wasn’t finished. After winning the U.S. Open, he set his sights on the U.S. Amateur at Merion Cricket Club to complete what George Trevor called the “impregnable quadrilateral of golf.” On September 27, he sealed the win with an 8-up lead over Eugene Homans, still having 7 holes to play.

The crowd at Merion was massive—around 18,000 fans, making it the largest gallery in U.S.G.A. history. An escort of 50 U.S. Marines had to be called in to protect Jones from the ecstatic crowd. Then, just over a month after completing the Grand Slam, Jones stunned the golfing world by retiring from tournament golf at the age of 28. He remains the only golfer to have won all four major tournaments—the British Amateur, British Open, U.S. Open, and U.S. Amateur—in a single year.

Finally, Chamblee concluded, “Majors are certainly A WAY to judge the best player of all time but it is problematic to be sure. I think the best way to judge the best player of all time is a combination of major wins and the level of dominance a player had in his or her era, measured by win % and margin of victories, compared to other eras over time. In that regard, Tiger is not just the greatest golfer of all time, he may well be the greatest athlete in the history of sports.”

Top Comment by Gregory Rish

I am so tired of this debate! Tiger was PGA Player of the Year 11 times and Jack had 5!...more

Share your take

Debate

However, as it turns out, the golf community does not agree with him.

The Golf World defends Jack Nicklaus

Brandel Chamblee, a former PGA Tour player turned outspoken analyst, has been a vocal critic of LIV Golf and Saudi Arabia’s influence on the game. But recently, he made a surprising revelation: a round of golf with President Donald Trump made him rethink Saudi Arabia’s role in the sport. This caught many golf fans off guard. One fan even commented, “What if Tiger’s wife didn’t beat his a**? What if he kept his original Masters win swing? What if you didn’t bend the knee to LIV?”

When it comes to golf legends, Jack Nicklaus is often at the top of the list, thanks to his record 18 major wins. But his collection of 19 runner-up finishes is nearly as impressive. No other player has come close to matching this record—only Arnold Palmer and Phil Mickelson have finished second in 10 or more majors.

Nicklaus’s first runner-up finish came in the 1960 U.S. Open when he was still an amateur, and his last came in the 1983 PGA Championship, with a remarkable 17 more second-place finishes in between. His near-misses span all four majors: four times in The Masters, four in the U.S. Open, seven in the British Open, and four in the PGA Championship.

This sparked plenty of debate, with some fans chiming in, “A lot of what ifs. Look at how many runner-ups and top-fives Nicklaus had in majors. In my opinion, Nicklaus is the greatest player ever. Want to talk about what-ifs? What if Ellen hadn’t stuck that club through Tiger’s window!” Another fan commented, “Disagree. Nicklaus is the GOAT not only for having more wins but also for having 37 2nd and 3rd place finishes. A record nobody touches, with a consistency of being in contention far more often than anybody. Also, you cannot play the what-if game. Longevity is part of the equation.”

One fan even put it simply: “Nicklaus had the greatest career. Woods played the greatest golf,” while another mockingly told Chamblee, “Put down the whiskey, Brandel.”

What do you think? Drop your thoughts in the comments below!