This February, in a heartwarming moment that showcased his impact beyond the golf course, Billy Horschel was honored with the prestigious Charlie Bartlett Award by the Golf Writers Association of America (GWAA). This special recognition celebrated his selfless contributions to society, a testament to his unwavering dedication to making the world a better place.

Then, Horschel was riding a wave of momentum at the RBC Heritage, where he came close to bagging his first-ever hole-in-one on the PGA Tour — the ball lipped out, leaving fans gasping. It was a moment that summed up his electric form and set the stage for what many expected to be a show-stopping appearance at the Zurich Classic. With his swing dialed in and confidence high, Horschel looked ready to light it up in New Orleans

Now, there are concerns about what’s going on behind the scenes, given his abrupt decision, particularly after joining Commissioner Jay Monahan to announce a sponsorship extension. So, let’s take a closer look at this recent story.

Billy Horschel’s sudden withdrawal from the Zurich Classic

The two-time Zurich Classic champion, Billy Horschel, unexpectedly pulled out of the competition just hours after he and PGA Tour Commissioner Jay Monahan attended an announcement about a sponsorship renewal. The PGA Tour Communications tweeted, “Billy Horschel WD from the Zurich Classic of New Orleans. Tom Hoge will now partner with first alternate Kevin Chappell.”

Horschel was by Monahan’s side when the Zurich Classic’s sponsorship extension through 2030 was announced earlier the same day. “PGA Tour commissioner Jay Monahan (center right), two-time Zurich champion Billy Horschel (right) at the announcement to extend sponsorship of @Zurich_Classic through 2030,” tweeted Scott Rabalais. Considering Horschel’s past involvement with the competition, the abrupt withdrawal sparked eyebrows among spectators and analysts.

However, Horschel tweeted just a while back in response to clear all the doubts about his withdrawal, stating, “Sucks to WD from @Zurich_Classic. Unfortunately, I have a lower-body injury. Hopefully, after a few days of rest, recovery, and therapy, I’ll be back and good to go. Congrats to @ZurichNA on the extension of the @Zurich_Classic thru 2030. Great news for everyone involved, especially the @forekidsnola and the city of New Orleans. I look forward to coming back and supporting this wonderful event for many years to come.”

The only player to win both individually and as a team is Horschel. In 2017, Zurich moved to a team format, and Horschel won the 2013 solo title and the 2018 team title with Scott Piercy. The eight-time PGA Tour champion’s recent starts have yielded a range of outcomes. Despite missing the cut at the Masters, he tied for 27th place at the RBC Heritage last week and tied for fourth at the Valspar Championship. He has made the weekend in seven of his 12 appearances this season and is now ranked 52nd in the FedEx Cup standings. Horschel’s place is being taken by first alternate Kevin Chappell, who will be paired with Tom Hoge.

The timing of Horschel’s most recent withdrawal and his subsequent public appearance alongside Monahan have sparked speculation about underlying issues. Fans and pundits alike are left wondering what circumstances led to this surprising decision, despite no official explanation having been given for his departure from the Zurich Classic. However, this is not the first time Horschel has withdrawn from an event. There has been an instance before. Let’s check that out!

A pattern of withdrawals: Horschel’s 3M Open exit in July 2024

Horschel’s decision to skip the Zurich Classic is not unique. He withdrew from the 3M Open in July 2024, claiming body aches and fever. He stated, “Unfortunately, had to withdraw from @3MOpen. Woke up with a fever, body aches, and back just locked up. Tried to warm up and give it a go but body just wouldn’t let it happen,” expressing his disappointment.

Horschel’s abrupt absences raise questions about his health and well-being. Even while sportsmen occasionally experience unanticipated health problems, Horschel’s situation is noteworthy for the frequency of these occurrences. Both observers and admirers are left wondering about the root issues and how they might affect his career. ​

The abrupt and inexplicable withdrawal of a well-known player like Horschel adds to the difficulties facing the PGA Tour, which is already grappling with issues such as complaints about slow play. Addressing these issues and maintaining the confidence of supporters and stakeholders will require transparency and open communication. ​