Otmar Szafnauer Labeled ‘Useless’ as Mattia Binotto’s Appointment Welcomed With Open Arms

Wow! So that’s what the Szafnauer-Permane sacking was about? Formula 1 never ceases to surprise its fans with sudden managerial changes, dramatic statements, and bold decisions. Alpine F1 made headlines as it initiated major shifts within its top management. The evictions included notable figures like Otmar Szafnauer from the main team, Alan Permane, the sporting director. Meanwhile, they also lost Pat Fry, a key figure in the technical department. Regardless, the French team seems to be making this a part of their plan to the top in F1. If so, the rumored appointment of Mattia Binotto should be the silver lining, Alpine wants to see.

On the same topic, Franck Montagny, a retired French professional racing driver and now gave profound insights and commentaries as the Alpine drama just keeps giving more and more not so “useless” news. Using his platform, Montagny held nothing back during his post-race Instagram Live in Belgium, where he candidly spoke about the recent Alpine F1 shake-ups. The majority of his comments hinted that Alpine is all set to welcome the new boss, Mattia Binotto.

Opening up his Instagram session, Montagny remarked, “I think that the morale of the troops [at Alpine] comes mainly from the fact that we fired [Alan] Permane and [Otmar] Szafnauer who were very sincerely useless.” Montagny’s views on Permane were deeply influenced by their shared history. He reminisced that he had already worked with Permane back in 2003 at Renault. There, due to mounting frustrations, he was transferred from the racing squad to the test team.

Elaborating further, Montagny said that once he joined the test team, his presence wearied everyone. Having spent 34 years with the team, he believed the decision to move him was a wise one. Montagny acknowledged his personal relationship with Bruno Famin, the interim Team Principal of the Alpine F1 Team, and appreciated his decisions, even if they seemed biased.

Read More: $218,000,000 License to Kill Allows Alpine to Recruit Mattia Binotto & Initiate Ambitious F1 Plans

Montagny also highlighted Permane’s attitudes towards French drivers, which is a sore spot for many F1 fans. Montagny disclosed, “You have to know that guys like Permane recently said that if they had a good engine and other drivers, it wasn’t a podium in Monaco, it was a double. You should also know that Permane does not support French pilots.”

Following Otmar Szafnauer & Alan Permane’s shock exit, Alpine compared to Toyota’s F1 endeavor

While Bruno Famin, the interim team boss, indicates mutual agreements behind Szafnauer and Permane’s departures, former F1 driver, Karun Chandhok expressed concerns about the larger ramifications for the team. Speaking to Sky Sports, Chandhok drew parallels with Toyota, which exited F1 in 2009 without achieving significant success.

Chandhok expressed, “I think we have to consider the massive wave of three heavy hitters departing at once. It suggests a significant shift, possibly hinting at problems from an operational and trackside perspective. But is that truly where the issues lie?” His concerns are regarding Alpine’s potential recruitment strategy. The larger worry is Alpine bringing in more management from outside of motorsport, outside of Formula 1, and perhaps from the road car industry. Toyota took a similar path two decades ago, moving in a non-F1, corporate direction. And we all remember how that turned out.

Toyota’s F1 journey ended after the 2009 season. Although they were well-funded, they couldn’t make a significant impact due to issues in management and driver management. Adding to the debate, Sky Sports’ David Croft queried Famin about the recent changes. When asked about Alpine’s goals, Famin ambitiously mentioned “wins and championships”. Croft, however, pointed out the challenges, especially with Alpine’s engine being considered the weakest on the grid.

The coming months will be crucial for Alpine as they navigate this period of transition. Their decisions, both on and off the track, will determine if they’re charting a path toward renewed success or if they’re treading the precarious road once taken by Toyota.

WATCH THIS STORY | Ricciardo Redemption, Frozen Bottas- Dramatic F1 Moments in Monaco GP History