Jake Paul‘s promotional venture, Most Valuable Promotions (MVP), celebrated starfighter Amanda Serrano for receiving the ‘Fight of the Year’ (FOTY) award for the third consecutive year. While most publications and organizations have yet to announce their choices for the prestigious honor, this recognition appears to be exclusive to MVP.

Nevertheless, it seems to have drawn quite a bit of attention. Last month, Amanda Serrano concluded her second fight of the year, facing her longtime rival Katie Taylor on the co-main event of the Jake Paul-Mike Tyson card. This rematch for Taylor’s light welterweight titles followed their iconic clash at Madison Square Garden on April 30, 2022.

Amanda Serrano’s 2023 highlights and historic rivalry with Katie Taylor

“Amanda “THE REAL DEAL” Serrano proving why she’s the GOAT! 3x Fight of the Year recipient! 🥊🏆 Read the message on MVP’s Instagram post. The post also highlighted her 2022 fight against Katie Taylor and last year’s victory over Erika Cruz as key moments in her career.

It is widely accepted that Serrano and Taylor’s first fight earned the 2022 ‘Fight of the Year’ accolade. However, the recognition of her bout against Erika Cruz may spark some debate. Regardless, Serrano’s consistent dominance and exceptional record in professional boxing remain unquestionable.

Alongside Claressa Shields and Katie Taylor, she has been instrumental in elevating women’s boxing to new heights, including securing paydays that rival those of male champions. MVP’s announcement drew mixed reactions from fans. Many supported the decision, while others felt Katie Taylor deserved equal acknowledgment. Let’s check what some of them had to say.

Questions surrounding the ‘Fight of the Year’ recognition

One fan pointed out Serrano’s impressive accomplishments across weight classes. “Let’s not forget all 3 in different weight classes: 135/126/140 & all for undisputed championships. 😉 Not a bad piece of unknown history in there, right, @nakisabidarian?” they shared tagging of the MVP co-founder, Nakisa Bidarian. The ‘FOTY’ part may remain debatable. The way Serrano moved across three weight divisions within 36 months clearly cements her legacy as one of the greatest boxers of all time.

The next one also agreed. They said, “Legit. Should’ve been the main event for the last one🔥.” The point was highlighted by several fans earlier. Serrano and Taylor headlined the event at Madison Square Garden. However, at the Cowboys Stadium, their rematch became a co-main event. Given it was the showdown they were more eager about, many diehards disapproved of the move.

Even Serrano’s losses didn’t dissuade this fan, who remarked, “Even though she lost two of those three fights, she’s my MVP.” While the Puerto Rican champion faced defeats against Katie Taylor, she triumphed over Erika Cruz last year. Her performances, particularly in her battles against Taylor, have secured her place in boxing history.

Not all fans were in agreement, though. “Katie Taylor is clearly the GOAT,” said one fan. Undoubtedly, the London Olympics gold winner is not only an icon in her homeland of Ireland, but she is now a global brand that has taken women’s boxing to another level. She suffered a loss last year. However, her amateur and professional journeys narrate an outstanding tale of perseverance and determination.

The following user had a similar question: “Why do you have no respect for Katie Taylor as a winner?” Given the fact that Taylor won both the outings against Serrano, they felt that the Irish boxing star had done enough to earn the respect she deserved.

It’s important to note that Katie Taylor defeated Amanda Serrano twice in the United States.

Discussions about the ‘Fight of the Year’ or the title of GOAT in boxing are inherently subjective. For example, BoxingScene awarded Katie Taylor versus Chantelle Cameron the 2023 ‘Fight of the Year’ (Women) award. However, Amanda Serrano’s contributions to boxing remain undeniable. She has paved the way for future generations and continues to inspire fans worldwide.

Do you agree with MVP’s recognition of Amanda Serrano as the ‘FOTY’ recipient? Or do you believe Katie Taylor deserves equal, if not greater, praise? Share your thoughts!