Canelo Alvarez has clinched the 2023 Fan’s Choice Award, sparking a whirlwind in the boxing world. But why is this win stirring such a debate? Álvarez, a titan in the ring, secured decisive victories against John Ryder and Jermell Charlo this year. His triumph over Ryder in Mexico marked a victorious homecoming.

Against Charlo, Álvarez showcased his dominance in an overwhelming win. Yet, amidst these victories lies an undercurrent of controversy. What makes Álvarez’s award so contentious? Is there more to this accolade than meets the eye?

WBC’s tribute to Canelo Alvarez

The World Boxing Council recently illuminated the boxing scene with a notable post on their Instagram. They energetically celebrated Saul “Canelo” Álvarez’s achievements in 2023. They declared,  “’Canelo’ remained very active in 2023 with two memorable fights. The first against John Ryder in his long-awaited return home and the second defeating Jermell Charlo in an overwhelming way. He masterfully conserved the undisputed super middleweight championship.”

This statement, laden with praise, highlights Álvarez’s dynamic year, showcasing his victories that resonated beyond the ring and into the hearts of fans worldwide. But were the fans in agreement with the WBC?

‘The fear factor: Is Alvarez avoiding Benavidez?

In response to the WBC’s announcement, the boxing community voiced a medley of opinions, each reflecting a unique perspective on Álvarez’s win. One fan, awed by Álvarez’s prowess, remarked, “The way Ryder got dropped! Crazy how people hate Canelo be like he had a bad performance lol.”

However, transitioning to a more critical view, another countered, “’Very active’ two fights, bro fought a bum and a champ two weights below fight Benavidez.” This response underscores a prevalent skepticism regarding the caliber of Álvarez’s opponents, igniting a debate over his choice of matches.

Adding to the mix, a supporter emphasized Álvarez’s stature, stating, “And still the face of boxing sells the most pay-per-view, attracts the most avid fans put on a spectacle. Every time he steps into the ring. Yeah, I’d say he’s still the face of boxing definitely.” This viewpoint highlights Álvarez’s influence on the sport beyond mere victories.

Yet, another fan questioned the selection of his opponents, pondering, “Canelo says Benavidez hasn’t fought anyone and doesn’t deserve a shot at him. My question is who has this B level boxer fought and why did he get a shot at Canelo? I’m beginning to think Canelo is in fact scared of Benavidez.” This challenges the narrative around Álvarez’s readiness to face all contenders.

Diverging from the mainstream discussion, one comment brought an unexpected name into the fray, suggesting, “The one who should get boxer of the year is [Jake Paul].”

His victories over Ryder and Charlo, while significant, have opened the floodgates to a multitude of questions and debates. From discussions about his choice of opponents to his undeniable influence on pay-per-view sales, Álvarez remains a central figure in the evolving narrative of modern boxing.

Also Read: Despite His Nose Fiasco in Last Fight, John Ryder Wants His “Chance” Again Against Canelo Alvarez

What is your take on Canelo Álvarez’s journey and his recent accolade? Do you believe he stands unchallenged as the face of boxing?

Watch this story: David Benavidez continues slamming Canelo Alvarez ahead of Andrade fight