“Excessive and Unnecessary”: Fitness Community Vehemently Disagrees With Exercise Scientist’s Advice on Carbs

Fitness enthusiasts and experts are in a heated debate following exercise scientist Dr. Mike Israetel’s controversial stance on carbohydrates. Recently, when asked about the optimal approach for performance, strength, and mass gain, Israetel emphasized the importance of a consistent intake of carbohydrates throughout the day.

In an interview snippet, Dr. Israetel candidly shared that the key lies in ensuring that the body has a sufficient amount of carbohydrates stored in muscle glycogen at all times. He stressed that consuming enough carbohydrates on a daily basis is crucial for fueling intense workouts and facilitating post-exercise recovery.

Dr. Israetel stated, “The most important thing is having enough carbohydrates in your diet period in any 24-hour cycle.” He highlighted that even if carbohydrate consumption is not perfectly timed around workouts, having an adequate overall intake is paramount for optimal performance, recovery, and muscle growth.

Using a hypothetical scenario, Dr. Israetel illustrated that consistently meeting the body’s carbohydrate needs, such as consuming 400 grams per day, outweighs precise timing strategies.“The way glycogen resynthesis works, because such a meal is going to be so slow digesting, you are going to be objectively better off in performance recovery and muscle growth,” Dr. Mike asserted.

He compared consuming 400 grams of carbohydrates in one meal to indulging in a late-night sushi feast, emphasizing that the body will still benefit from glycogen resynthesis and experience improvements in performance, recovery, and muscle growth. This revelation sparked controversy within the fitness community, with some experts and enthusiasts disagreeing with Dr. Israetel’s stance.

Israetel receives major criticism for his 400-gram carb suggestion

The online fitness community called his advice “Excessive and unnecessary.” One fitness enthusiast disagreed with Dr. Mike and said, “The 400g carb is unnecessary and probably one of the worst advice to give. There’s just no need.” One user questioned whether the advice about consuming 400 grams of carbs was a joke, “Please tell me this is an April Fools prank.”

Nonetheless, the comments didn’t end there. One emphasized the importance of considering the context and wrote, “Context is extremely important here. I watch people train, and very few of them would deplete glycogen to necessitate 400g of carbs to replenish. A bodybuilder, a young kid bulking, etc.. makes sense. A middle-aged man looking to improve his physique def doesn’t need that many carbs.”

READ MORE: “You’re Technically in Junk Volume”: Exercise Scientist Gives a Reality Check for People Not Making Progress Despite Working Out Hard

While emphasizing the significance of meeting daily carbohydrate needs, Israetel’s stance challenges conventional beliefs surrounding timing and distribution. Let us know if you also believe in Dr. Mike Israetel’s advice or if you disagree with him.

READ MORE: Exercise Scientist Gives a Harsh Reality Check to People Seeking Motivation to Go to the Gym: “You Don’t Want It Enough”